Tuesday, December 09, 2025

2025, ANOTHER TYPICALLY ATYPICAL YEAR

El Taladro Azul

M. Juan Szabo [1] y Luis A. Pacheco [2]

Published  Originally in Spanish in  LA GRAN ALDEA    



The year 2025, the final year of the first quarter of the 21st century, emerged as a turning point in the global landscape, marked by geopolitical fragmentation, shifts in the world order driven by a new vision from Washington, conflicts proving difficult to resolve, and a pragmatic yet uneven energy transition in which fossil fuels defended their market position.


Global Geopolitics

Changes in geopolitical dynamics have accelerated, with confrontations between rival blocs—the West versus the China and Russia-led Axis—alongside some peace agreements, the most important of which appears destined to pacify the Middle East. Also in full development are the search for solutions to the Russia-Ukraine conflict and the Venezuelan crisis.


To date, though now relegated to the back pages of the news, the most significant outcome is undoubtedly the dismantling of the threat Iran posed had it succeeded in developing nuclear weapons. A well-designed campaign of attrition and a precise strike against Iranian power, its regional terrorism network, and its nuclear facilities by Israel and the U.S., met with indifference from other regional actors, has significantly restrained and delayed the Iranian nuclear threat. Meanwhile, sanctions have eroded Iran's capacity to finance its proxies that spread terrorism worldwide.


Energy and Markets

On the energy front, demand continues growing, driven by economic electrification, artificial intelligence (AI) requirements, and regional economic development. Geopolitics once again plays a leading role in conflicts over access to energy resources, transforming energy into a weapon of strategic influence.


In any event, due to numerous factors, oil prices have remained in a downward trend, losing nearly 20% of their value over the year. It is difficult to estimate how much of this behavior stems from President Trump's actions versus market forces. Still, the result aligns with his demands to limit inflation and motivate the Federal Reserve (Fed) and other central banks to stimulate economies.


Multipolarity and Tensions

The year 2025 consolidates an unstable multipolar world in which Trump's strategies and the reactions of his allies and adversaries revolve around three central themes: economic sovereignty, technological rivalries, and climate pressures as risk multipliers.


China, with its expansionist ambitions in the South China Sea, advances in AI, and control over strategic minerals, challenges U.S. dominance. The United States imposes secondary sanctions, limits exports, and takes other economic measures to halt China's post-pandemic economic recovery policies temporarily. A temporary "transactional agreement" is expected to mitigate domestic economic tensions. Still, fragmentation into commercial blocs with new "nodes" in India, Brazil, and Africa persists, raising the risk of "fiscal wars" and cyberattacks, with a geopolitical premium already reflected in gold prices.


Energy Transition

Energy in 2025 reflects the pursuit—thus far unsuccessful—of a balance between climate change mitigation policies and economic realities. Global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are projected to exceed 2024 levels; nonetheless, energy demand growth, driven by data centers and electrification, requires record investments in both fossil and renewable energy sources. The year will close with an energy mix in which fossil fuels still dominate, accounting for 78% of usage. The inconclusive outcomes of the COP30 conference in Brazil illustrate the complexity of the trade-offs between development and climate change.


Oil and Gas Demand

In this context, global oil demand grew by 1.2 million barrels per day (MMbpd), reaching 105.2 MMbpd by year's end, supported by petrochemical demand and growth in emerging economies. Natural gas demand grew 4% in the U.S., and, unlike oil, gas prices remained elevated due to sanctions on Russia, one of the largest producers, and rising demand for liquefied natural gas (LNG).


Energy Geopolitics

In summary, energy, as is well known, is the core of geopolitics. Conflicts such as Ukraine-Russia, instability, and military skirmishes have threatened fossil fuel supplies, while the race for critical minerals (lithium, cobalt, copper, rare earths) has fragmented supply chains, with China controlling 60% of their processing. Trump's energy policy prioritizes increased global production of oil and natural gas, as well as LNG exports, while tariffs delay the incorporation of imported renewables. Opportunities arise in alliances: BRICS countries push to break the dollar standard and the current economic order.


OPEC Strategies

In this context, OPEC and OPEC+ have been implementing strategies to maintain oil's relevance over time while balancing member countries' fiscal needs with the potential for demand destruction from excessively high prices. Threats of overproduction for 2026 continue to weigh on prices and represent the most critical factor to monitor in the coming months. The question we face is whether we are closer to "peak demand" than to "peak oil."


PRICE DYNAMICS

During the week, oil prices remained range-bound, though with some improvement. Markets weighed news of a possible increase in Russian oil exports, reduced CPC Blend exports from Kazakhstan, possible military action in Venezuela, rising U.S. inventories, and a possible Fed interest rate cut in December. The profound uncertainty surrounding the balance between demand and supply truncated the attempted price recovery. Nevertheless, at Friday's market close on December 5, the benchmark crudes, Brent and WTI, traded at $63.75 and $60.08/bbl, respectively, a 5% increase compared to the previous week's close.


VENEZUELA

Everything Collapsed

At the beginning of 2025, it appeared that the repercussions of fraud in the 2024 presidential elections had been contained and their significance diluted over time—just another episode in the long chain of political abuses by the Chavista regime. Control of prior years' hyperinflation led to talk of economic growth based on oil activity, supported by OFAC oil licenses granted to foreign operators such as Chevron, Repsol, Maurel & Prom, among others.


Policy Shift

But the winds changed direction. Donald Trump's arrival at the White House, Marco Rubio's appointment as Secretary of State, and pressure from Latino parliamentarians in Congress changed the dynamics of the relationship between Caracas and Washington.


The oil licenses granted by the Biden administration were canceled in their entirety. Although a new license was subsequently issued, this time privately and only for the American oil company Chevron, it has, as expected, provided only limited benefits to the economy, which remains constrained by the Maduro administration's restrictive policies.


Economic Crisis

This new sanctions scheme, together with falling international oil prices, slowly eroded foreign currency revenues; by year's end, the reduction reached 40% compared to the foreign currency entering at the beginning of the year. The foreign currency shortage, month by month, undermined the economic framework despite the efforts and sacrifices of economic actors. The government reduced public spending to mitigate Central Bank monetary financing, devalued the currency in a controlled manner, and attempted to suppress the parallel exchange market forcibly.


After months of adjustments and controls, the economy continues to contract. The bolivar has devalued 400% so far this year, and the gap with alternative dollar markets has surged again to 60%, despite the regime injecting increasingly large amounts of dollars into these markets at prices substantially above the official rate, currently at 258 Bs/$; it is estimated to reach 300 Bs/$ before year's end.


International Pressure

The possibility of a government change is increasingly mentioned, with even official sources discussing transitional proposals. It is rumored that in the much-touted phone call between Maduro and Trump, the latter gave Maduro a very short deadline to abandon his current position and, if he refused, he would "have to face the consequences"; still, Maduro characterized the call as cordial. Both pieces of information come from unofficial but apparently well-connected sources close to the centers of power.

International pressure on the Maduro administration is increasingly intense and escalating; it began early in the year with a policy of maximum oil and financial pressure, followed by legal proceedings in the U.S. through which Maduro and his closest acolytes were formally charged with narcoterrorism as kingpins of the Cartel of the Suns and the Tren de Aragua, and with maintaining relationships with Mexican cartels and armed terrorist gangs operating in Venezuela and Colombia.


Military Escalation

Subsequently, the U.S. escalated to the military pressure stage, deploying a naval force in the Caribbean, ostensibly to control drug trafficking. That force's actions have been eliminating vessels allegedly transporting narcotics. To date, approximately 23 boats have been eliminated along with more than 80 human casualties, and although these actions have been questioned in the U.S. Congress, they continue. In parallel, the U.S. fleet and its aircraft have escalated flights along the limits of Venezuelan airspace, and naval vessels have deployed radars in various parts of the Caribbean. Most recently, Trump declared Venezuelan airspace a no-fly zone, reducing commercial flights in and out of the country to a minimum. A situation of uncertainty, economic lethargy, and expectation has taken hold of the country.


Reflection

That Venezuela has gone from being a nation with a promising future and one of the natural allies of the United States in the hemisphere to the target of potential military action is something no Venezuelan can or should celebrate. It is a historical lesson in how an authoritarian regime, elected initially by popular vote, seeks and manages to isolate the country for the sole purpose of fraudulently remaining in power, at the expense of the present and future well-being of its citizens.


Future Prospects

On the other hand, most analysts continue to see significant oil growth potential in Venezuela if there is substantial political change. However, these same analysts differ on when and how this potential will materialize, both because of the complexity of implementing the necessary fiscal and institutional changes to attract massive investments and because of global supply-and-demand dynamics.



OIL OPERATIONS

Production

During 2025, production remained relatively unaffected by sanctions and license changes. Operational inertia and the use of service companies for well maintenance ensured relative continuity. Production during the year increased 4.5% according to OPEC secondary sources and remained constant, with a mid-year peak, according to our internal calculations. Both results indicate that current conditions are not conducive to materially increasing production, not even under the protection of the Anti-Blockade Law.


Refining and Petrochemicals

Refining, despite various repair and maintenance attempts, remained between 200 and 250 kbpd, representing less than 20% of installed capacity.

Petrochemical activity at the José complex has been a solid foreign currency generator both from product sales—methanol, ammonia, and urea—and from natural gas purchases; in fact, volumes processed have been limited by gas availability.


Accidents

Accidents were a regrettable and unsurprising constant throughout the year. The accident that occurred at the end of 2024 at the Muscar gas complex in the eastern part of the country kept natural gas and gas liquids availability limited throughout the year. Volumes of flared and vented gas also increased in northern Anzoátegui until August, when part of the gas was collected and injected into reservoirs. Accidents at the José complex and terminal have affected the integrity of upgraders and the handling of diluent imports necessary for Orinoco Belt production. A significant number of accidents in electrical transmission and distribution systems have affected economic activities in several regions of the country, including oil operations.


Marketing

In any case, hydrocarbon sales revenues were most affected by the political situation, limiting the markets and conditions under which Venezuelan crude could be placed. Indeed, during the suspension of OFAC licenses, all crude had to be sent to China, but through unorthodox mechanisms such as ghost tankers, intermediaries, ship-to-ship transfers, and sea-blending to relabel the crude's origin.

Since the new Chevron license took effect, approximately 130,000 barrels per day (kbpd) have been placed into the U.S. market. The rest is being sent to China with the described difficulties, except for a smaller volume sent to Cuba under notoriously opaque commercial conditions.


This export scheme yields weighted compensation well below the theoretical value of the crudes due to additional costs incurred and discounts that must be offered, given competition from other sanctioned crudes entering the same market.


Weekly Production

Finally, this week's production was similar to last week's due to the timely arrival of diluent from Chevron. Average weekly production was 859 thousand barrels per day, distributed geographically as follows:

  • West: 232 (Chevron: 107)
  • East: 117
  • Orinoco Belt: 510 (Chevron: 127)
  • TOTAL: 859 (Chevron: 234)

CITGO

The lawsuit against the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, which began eight years ago in the courts of Delaware, U.S., finally concluded in November 2025 with an order to sell the shares of PDV Holdings, Inc., the parent company of CITGO Petroleum. This long and convoluted lawsuit started when the Canadian mining company Crystallex sued the republic for the Maduro administration's breach of the compensation payment agreement for the expropriation of its operations in Venezuela during Hugo Chávez's time.


Still, this is not the end of the saga. Execution of the purchase and sale agreement requires an OFAC license. Until then, the sale will remain pending. At the same time, Venezuelan parties have already filed with the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, which could suspend the sale order until appeals are resolved.


Both conditions—the OFAC license and the suspension—are essential, given the different timelines of the purchase and sale agreement and the transaction support agreement signed with PDVSA 2020 bondholders, who are also part of this transaction.


[1]: International Analyst
[2]: Nonresident Fellow, Baker Institute

 

Tuesday, December 02, 2025

EXPECTATIONS OF OVERSUPPLY AFFECT THE OIL MARKET

 El Taladro Azul

M. Juan Szabo [1] y Luis A. Pacheco [2]

Published  Originally in Spanish in  LA GRAN ALDEA   



The oil market this week was marked by resilience amid expectations of excess supply and uncertainty about global demand. OPEC+ decisions and geopolitical tensions centered on the U.S., Russia, Ukraine, and Venezuela added volatility to oil prices.

The increase in commercial crude inventories in the U.S., doubts about the veracity of OPEC's numbers, and the International Energy Agency's (IEA) change in perspective further confused market participants. Additionally, on Friday, a cooling system failure at the CME Group (Chicago Mercantile Exchange) data center suspended futures and options operations, interrupting oil futures trading as well as equities, bonds, and currencies, just as prices were recovering.

CME Group is the leading international derivatives market and the venue where investors manage risks. Fortunately, at the time of the suspension, operations were at relatively low levels due to the U.S. Thanksgiving holiday.

GEOPOLITICS

News about negotiations on peace plans in the Russia-Ukraine conflict, or about the easing of sanctions-related tensions on Russian crude, provided some relief to markets, helping counter potential supply risks and preventing price spikes.

Ukraine and Russia

For Ukraine, a week is a long time. On November 19, reports emerged about a "peace plan" secretly negotiated between Russia and the U.S., which Ukrainians perceived, at first, as a demand for capitulation. By the weekend, European, Ukrainian, and American officials met in Geneva for an emergency summit to review that proposal. On November 26, American and Russian negotiators finalized their consultations in Abu Dhabi on the revised draft. Those familiar with the latest conversations say the document is still being revised. Ukraine is more satisfied with the latest version, but no one believes Vladimir Putin will accept it.

The negotiation process is tilting against Ukraine, which would lose territory without any guarantee of future security. The talks seek to reconcile Russian demands with Ukrainian concessions—undoubtedly two antagonistic positions that negotiators will have to reconcile if a reasonably happy ending is desired. The prolongation of the conversations, which weakened last week's hopes for a quick resolution, has kept the oil market stumbling as alleged details about the negotiations are leaked. Geopolitical volatility continues, and hopes of a possible ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine have, for now, neutralized supply concerns stemming from new U.S. sanctions against major Russian producers.

To try to accelerate the process, U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff is scheduled to travel to Moscow next week along with other senior U.S. officials to hold talks with Russian leaders about a possible plan to end the nearly four-year war in Ukraine, the deadliest in Europe since World War II.

Meanwhile, a Ukrainian attack on the port of Novorossiysk damaged one of three loading points at the Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC) terminal, through which more than 1% of global oil exports are shipped. Analysts stated that shipments from the terminal have been reduced by half due to the attacks. In any case, Chevron stated on Monday that tanker loading had resumed.

Also on Friday, several explosions rocked two tankers from Russia's shadow fleet in the Black Sea, near the Bosphorus Strait in Turkey, causing fires on board and initiating rescue operations, Turkish authorities and sources said. The tankers Kairos and Virat are receiving assistance in the Black Sea. Russia has also intensified its attacks on Kyiv to pressure the Ukrainian government, which is simultaneously facing a corruption scandal in its senior government.

Iraqi Kurdistan

Another region in conflict is Iraqi Kurdistan. The Khor Mor gas field, one of the largest gas fields in Iraq's semi-autonomous region, has been shut down following a rocket attack that hit a storage tank and caused a fire, the field's joint operator said Thursday, Dana Gas, a company based in the United Arab Emirates. A new condensate storage tank and export units were affected. The rocket attack is the most serious on a field in Kurdistan since mid-July, when three days of drone attacks on oil fields in the semi-autonomous region paralyzed much of the production.

Neither Kurdistan's oil production nor exports were affected. Still, the Khor Mor gas field, which supplies gas for domestic electricity generation and is in a precarious production state, was affected, accounting for 10% of total generation. The attack is presumed to have been perpetrated by militias backed by Iran and Iraq.

Middle East

In the Middle East, an intermittent ceasefire continues, as Israel has continued eliminating Palestinian operatives or detaining them when terrorist activity is detected in the area. Israel maintains that this is part of the next phase of the agreements: the disarmament of Hamas. In a curious development, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu requested a pardon from the nation's president in the corruption trial he is facing, a request that appears to pose significant legal and political complexities.

FUNDAMENTALS

OPEC+ policies, which include moderate production increases, seek, according to the cartel, to maintain market stability, although doubts persist about its ability to prevent a surplus in the coming months. There are also doubts about the sincerity of its production announcements; some renowned analysts question whether even measurements from its secondary sources could be accurate.

We believe that the capacity to add incremental production immediately is not possible, except in exceptional cases such as Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE), though not materially. Moreover, productions reported by secondary sources, unlike those of producing countries, better reflect reality. Some members of the group, which produces approximately half of the world's oil, have been increasing production since April to gain market share, but they appear to have reached their limits, for now.

OPEC+ Decisions

This last Sunday in November, in a virtual OPEC+ meeting, Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iraq, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Kuwait, Kazakhstan, Algeria, and Oman "reaffirmed their decision, made on November 2, 2025, to pause production increases in January, February, and March 2026 due to seasonality."

This apprehension about volumes, coupled with the announcements of increases that OPEC+ has been making, somewhat exaggerated in our opinion, has created a scenario of excess supply at levels only seen during the pandemic, which most oil market participants seem to consider likely. This overproduction, if it materializes, will keep prices depressed during December and much of 2026.

Global Production Outlook

The countries that, according to forecasters including the International Energy Agency (IEA), are expected to increase production over the next 13 months are the U.S., Canada, Brazil, Guyana, and Argentina. Guyana, which has experienced vertiginous development, has already reached a maximum production of 900,000 barrels per day (Mbpd) with the incorporation of the fourth FPSO (Floating Production Storage and Offloading) unit, and no incremental production is contemplated until the arrival of the 5th unit in 2027. As for Brazil, the incorporation and ramp-up of new FPSOs barely exceed the decline of fields in production. Argentina, on the contrary, will grow continuously but slowly; we must remember that this is an unconventional development with its enormous declines. Thus, the supply increase, both from OPEC+ and from non-cartel countries, could be more modest than the forecasts the market seems to be following.

United States Situation

In the U.S., drilling rig and hydraulic fracturing crew activity have declined so far this year, complemented by a considerable drop in DUC wells (drilled but uncompleted wells): a 25% reduction since January 2025. According to Baker Hughes, this week, probably due to price prospects, the reduction in active rigs accelerated; we observed a drop of 12 rigs in oil activity and a modest increase of 3 rigs in gas basins. A combination incapable of orchestrating short-term growth.

The Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported that commercial crude inventories in the U.S. increased by 2.7 million barrels; the market reacted to the news, but the movement was due to higher crude imports and not to a suggestion of limited demand.

Change in IEA Demand Outlook

On the demand side, the International Energy Agency (IEA) predicted in 2023 that the global peak in oil demand would likely be reached in 2030, as governments worldwide introduced plans for a green transition and fossil fuel companies began diversifying their portfolios to include renewable alternatives. However, this month the IEA retracted this prediction, stating that oil demand could continue to grow until 2050. This reflects a change of course by many countries in their climate commitments and by oil sector companies in their efforts to diversify their energy sources.

In the IEA's World Energy Outlook report, published in November, the organization retracted its earlier prediction, suggesting that global oil and gas demand could continue to grow until mid-century, 20 years longer than anticipated. Demand will be driven by industry, residential energy, and the technology sector, as various companies invest heavily in high-energy-consuming data centers to support the deployment of advanced technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI).

According to the Current Policies Scenario (CPS), the IEA predicts that oil demand will reach 113 million barrels by 2050, representing a 13% increase over 2024 consumption, as governments prioritize their energy security over the transition to renewable energy. This year, for the first time since 2019, the IEA used a scenario based on existing government policies rather than climate ambitions, perhaps due to pressure from the Trump administration's policy changes.

Other Market Factors

On the other hand, growing expectations of a December interest rate cut by the U.S. Federal Reserve limited the decline in crude prices. A lower rate typically stimulates economic growth and increases oil demand.

On the other side of the world, China's independent refineries, the so-called teapots, have just received their new increased crude import quotas for 2026. And the timing couldn't be more opportune, as significant volumes of sanctioned crude are seeking destinations in China; these are discounted Iranian, Venezuelan, and Russian cargoes that generally arrive with altered documentation.

Price Behavior

Oil prices on Thursday showed signs of a rebound at the end of the week, but a data center outage forced CME Group to suspend futures and options trading, disrupting oil futures as well as equities, bonds, and currencies. Barrel prices failed to lift their heads and were heading toward their fourth consecutive monthly loss.

Low trading volumes in the U.S. following Thanksgiving, aggravated by a CME blackout, have contributed to price calm. It is unlikely that OPEC+'s announcement will influence confidence in either direction.

Thus, at the close of markets on Friday, November 28, the benchmark crudes, Brent and WTI, were trading at $62.38 and $58.55/bbl, respectively, practically at the same level as at the close of the previous week.

VENEZUELA

A Country Under Suspicion

Venezuela's geopolitical situation continues to be marked by significant tension with the U.S., which this week escalated to warnings of Venezuelan airspace closure and an increase in U.S. military presence in the Caribbean.

U.S. President Donald Trump issued warnings about a possible closure of Venezuelan airspace, characterized by Caracas as a "colonialist threat." This situation led to the suspension of direct flights to Venezuela by most foreign airlines serving the country. Nicolás Maduro's government responded by putting the military aviation on alert, activating defense systems, and unilaterally canceling the routes of airlines that had suspended their flights. At the same time, social and political leaders perceived as opposition have been arrested, without respecting the rights that the Constitution guarantees to all citizens.

Despite the military escalation and rhetoric, there were reports of a telephone conversation between Trump and Maduro, which the U.S. president confirmed on Sunday, November 30, although without giving details about what was discussed. Actions such as the U.S. designation of the "Cartel of the Suns" as a terrorist group generated speculation about possible future implications. Visits by the Secretary of Defense to deployed troops, by General Cane to Trinidad, and the increase in the military presence in the Dominican Republic, as well as joint U.S.-Guyana military exercises, did not help calm the situation.

On the other hand, in Washington, Congress has initiated an investigation into the probability that military actions against some vessels allegedly transporting drugs and the killing of their crews constitute war crimes. An investigation that provides ammunition to those who oppose U.S. military pressure in the Caribbean.

Economic Situation

Regarding the economy, the fight against the exchange rate gap has become more complex than expected. The shortage of foreign currency has not been addressed by reducing public spending during months with traditionally higher disbursements, nor by sliding the official exchange rate; the priority supply of foreign currency at rates considerably higher than official ones has not been effective either, due to problems in managing cryptocurrencies to avoid American interference. In any case, the official exchange rate devalued to nearly 250 Bs./$, a year-to-date devaluation of around 375%; the exchange rate gap stubbornly remains at 42%. Inflation is neither published nor discussed in Venezuela, but Prof. Steve Hanke, a scholar of the matter, anticipates that inflation is on the threshold of hyperinflation.

Oil Operations

Diluent Situation

In the oil sector, amid continued reliance on Russian naphtha as a diluent, Venezuela is once again turning to Chevron to secure naphtha supplies. Indeed, the tanker Nave Neutrino, chartered by Chevron, is transporting diluent from the Virgin Islands. Naphtha supplies are scarce in Venezuela following an explosion at PetroCedeño that reduced the capacity to separate diluent from virgin crude, and the problems faced by one of the sanctioned ships attempting to reach the Jose terminal.

During the week, the operational situation was marked by continuity of activity, despite the aftermath of the recent accident at PetroCedeño. There was also a reduction in natural gas availability at the Jose complex in the eastern part of the country, which affected petrochemical activity and had repercussions on foreign currency flow.

Average production for the week was eight hundred sixty thousand barrels per day (860 Mbpd), due to the production shutdown related to the accident, geographically distributed as follows:

  • West: 231 (Chevron: 108)
  • East: 117
  • Orinoco Belt: 513 (Chevron: 127)
  • TOTAL: 861 (Chevron: 235)

National refineries processed 226 Mbpd of crude and intermediate products, yielding 76 Mbpd of gasoline and 78 Mbpd of diesel.

In the petrochemical sector, one methanol plant was shut down due to a lack of natural gas, and Fertinitro plants are at risk of shutdown due to excess inventory.

November's export, with just a few days left to close the month, is unclear. We estimate that an average of 630 Mbpd of crude will be exported this month, mostly to China, with about 127 Mbpd to the U.S. via Chevron's license and 40 Mbpd to Cuba.

We estimate the weighted price of exported crude at $30.6/bbl.

CITGO

In the Federal Court of Delaware, Judge Leonard Stark approved on Tuesday, November 25, a $5.9 billion offer from Amber Energy, a subsidiary of Elliott Investment Management, in the court-organized auction of PDV Holding, the parent company of Citgo Petroleum, clearing the way for the sale of PDV Holding. The offer that Judge Stark considered the most appropriate also provides a $2.1 billion payment to holders of the PDVSA 2020 bond, a defaulted Venezuelan bond secured by Citgo shares, whose legality is still being litigated in New York courts.

"If OFAC grants a license to Amber Energy, and if this Court's judgment is not reversed on appeal, many of the judgment creditors who have spent years and millions of dollars trying to recover billions of dollars in judgments, to compensate them for the harm inflicted by one or more of the Venezuelan parties years or decades ago, will finally obtain relief," wrote Judge Stark.

In any case, and as expected, lawyers representing Venezuela, PDVSA ad hoc, Citgo Petroleum, and its parent companies appealed Judge Stark's decision on Monday, December 1, to the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals. The appellants allege that "the forced sale process has been characterized by deficiencies and irregularities, including a conflict-of-interest involving court advisors." Other actors in the process, creditors and bidders in the auction, are also expected to file appeals.

This endless and sad saga will continue at least until 2026, according to legal experts.

[1]: International Analyst
[2]: Nonresident Fellow Baker Institute

 

Tuesday, November 25, 2025

PEACE PLAN FOR UKRAINE AND RUSSIA PUSHES OIL PRICES DOWN

El Taladro Azul

M. Juan Szabo [1] y Luis A. Pacheco [2]

Published  Originally in Spanish in  LA GRAN ALDEA   


The resumption of Russian port operations in the Black Sea, the entry into force of sanctions against Russian oil companies, and the decline in U.S. commercial crude inventories maintained volatility in the oil market. However, the news that weighed most heavily on prices was the possible resolution to the military conflict between Ukraine and Russia, after it became public that the White House had agreed with the Kremlin on a plan to end the conflict.

Indeed, following the apparent success of President Trump's 30-point plan for Gaza, at least regarding the cessation of hostilities, the market reacted to the announcement of a 28-point proposal to end the war between Russia and Ukraine. The mere fact that Putin appears inclined to accept said proposal considerably reduced the perception of geopolitical risk that had been established in the markets due to the continuous "give and take" of the conflict, which has resulted in Russian advances in eastern Ukraine and significant deterioration of Russian oil infrastructure. Added to this were sanctions that were eroding Russia's oil supply to the market. The new expectation of security in Russian oil supply kept oil prices below those of the previous week.

Meanwhile, refined product markets are experiencing a boom, as middle distillate (gas oil) refining margins reach their highest level in nearly three years, primarily driven by European Union (EU) sanctions on Russian petroleum products and the fact that more than 15% of Russian refining capacity has been affected by Ukrainian attacks.

In Belém, Brazil, COP30 ended with considerable disagreements and some agreements well below the expectations of organizations seeking to accelerate the reduction of fossil fuel use. China's silence and the U.S.'s absence left Europeans bearing the weight of financial commitments. After 30 of these conferences, perhaps it is time to reconsider whether this is still the mechanism for advancing climate change management agreements.

GEOPOLITICS

The strategic, commercial, and technological rivalries between the U.S. and China continue to be the main catalysts of 21st-century geopolitics, influencing the global economy, supply chains, and technological governance. Russia is making efforts to insert itself into that select group, using its nuclear arsenal as a banner and supporting China in its objective to reconfigure the world order and challenge the existing multilateral system. Meanwhile, Europe (including the United Kingdom) debates whether it has a role to play in these scenarios.

Against this backdrop, short-term geopolitics unfolds at the world's tension points: Eastern Europe, the Middle East, and a relatively new tension between Japan and China regarding Taiwan, an immediacy that may or may not extend over time.

Ukraine and Russia

This week, the focus returns to Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky faces a confluence of crises that tests his convening power in a country exhausted by nearly four years of devastating confrontation with Russia.

Pressure on Zelensky has intensified as Trump pushes a proposal developed together with Russia that would require significant territorial and military concessions from Ukraine—and, apparently, few from Russia—to end the war. According to Reuters, Kyiv would have to relinquish the entire Donbas region and significantly reduce its army, terms that Ukraine's supporters have long considered, for practical purposes, a surrender. In parallel, Zelensky is trying to contain the internal repercussions of a corruption scandal involving senior officials and other associates.

All this unfolds while Russia makes slow but steady advances in eastern Ukraine and relentlessly bombs power plants, causing severe electricity outages as colder weather sets in. However, it should not be forgotten that, contrary to what the Trump proposal tacitly assumes, Russia also faces economic and military problems.

Zelensky said he has received a 28-point peace plan, drafted jointly by the U.S. and Russia, and that he is willing to work on it immediately. He also expects to speak with U.S. President Donald Trump in the coming days. For now, EU leaders and Zelensky are holding urgent consultations at the G20 summit in Johannesburg, seeking a common position amid the geopolitical earthquake driven by the White House. The U.S. plan for Ukraine breaks into the G-20, notable for the absence of Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Chinese President Xi, although these details do not seem to affect the market's immediate reaction.

Despite the complexity of the negotiations that may or may not occur, the market seems to interpret the process as a light at the end of the tunnel, and oil prices fell sharply on Friday, without assigning much value to the sanctions against Russian oil companies, Rosneft and Lukoil, which were about to enter into force.

Middle East

Regarding the conflict in the Middle East, the UN Security Council is scheduled to vote this Monday on a resolution to take Gaza beyond the fragile truce that entered into force last month, toward a more sustainable peace and reconstruction. Its main features include a Peace Board, trained by Egypt, to administer Gaza for two years. The Board would oversee the disarmament of Hamas and other factions—a key Israeli demand—as well as Gaza's reconstruction, with support from international forces and Palestinian police.

The resolution is based on President Trump's peace plan, presented in September, but already faces opposition from some members of the Israeli government and could suffer a veto from Russia, China, or both, when the vote comes.

FUNDAMENTALS

The dynamics of oil fundamentals did not impress the market much, despite a 3.4 million-barrel drop in U.S. commercial crude inventories, which remain below the range of the last 5 years. Crude production potential generation activities, both in rigs and fracturing crews, show ups and downs but remain at constant average levels, maintaining stability.

At the same time, the most recent U.S. employment report, published on Thursday, dispelled hopes of a Federal Reserve interest rate cut in December. The data showed an unexpected addition of 119,000 jobs for September; the unemployment rate increased to 4.4% and previous months were revised downward. Markets interpreted the data as a weakening of the argument for imminent monetary easing, which, in turn, weakens support for oil demand.

"Given the Fed's recent more aggressive turn and the lack of scheduled official data before the December 10 FOMC meeting, it is understandable that the market thinks the next move will not come until early 2026," ING bank analysts said in a note.

China

On the Chinese side, oil demand appears to have recovered, based on the high refining margins prevailing in the market, to the point that the central government increased crude quotas for private refineries (teapots). The reduction in Russian crude purchases by both China and India is affecting the scheme and volume of Russian exports.

China is importing unusually large quantities of crude oil from Indonesia, a trend that, according to traders, is intended to mask shipments of sanctioned Iranian crude transshipped through Malaysian waters amid increased scrutiny of Malaysian-origin shipments.

Price Dynamics

Over the last week, oil prices continued to decline amid concerns that a global supply surplus will materialize, but above all due to the reaction to the diplomatic rapprochement between the U.S. and Russia regarding the war in Ukraine.

Thus, at the close of markets on Friday, November 21, the market crudes, Brent and WTI, were trading at $62.56/bbl and $58.56/bbl, respectively, a loss of almost 3% from the previous week’s close.

VENEZUELA

Change or Continuity?

Over the weekend, more than six airlines canceled flights to and from Venezuela after the United States Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) warned civil aviation of an "increase in military activity" amid the deployment of U.S. forces in the Caribbean, the Venezuelan airline association told AP.

These unexpected cancellations are the most recent result of the escalation of military tensions between the U.S. and Venezuela, nominally against the "Cartel of the Suns." Washington assures that this cartel, which it designates as drug trafficking, is headed by Nicolás Maduro. This cartel, as announced by U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, will be designated as a foreign terrorist organization on Monday, November 24. Designating organizations as foreign terrorist groups grants U.S. law enforcement and military greater legal powers to attack and dismantle them, hence the warning about airspace.

On the other hand, perhaps as the other jaw of the pincers, President Donald Trump assured this Friday that he will soon speak with Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro to tell him "something very specific." So the credible military threat in the Caribbean and its legal justification under U.S. laws, and the supposed pending conversation between Trump and Maduro, seem to presage that something is about to change. The only certainty is that the current situation is unsustainable from any perspective.

In the Caribbean, the tanker 'Seahorse', which was transporting Russian naphtha to Venezuela, was intercepted by the United States Navy. The tanker changed course, not without attempting twice more to reach its destination. Finally, it returned to the Cuban port of Matanzas, where it had been, and from where it set sail again with an unknown destination. This naval skirmish (blockade?) affects the availability of diluent for mixing Merey 16 crude.

On the other hand, the economy continues to be affected by the geopolitical environment of sanctions and, now, by a possible naval blockade. Despite the administration's sacrifices in public spending and an increasingly disproportionate distribution between the foreign currency offered at the official rate and that provided on cryptocurrency platforms at considerably higher levels, the gap stubbornly remained above 40%. At the close of markets, the official exchange rate stood at 243 Bs./$, up 3% from the previous week.

The National Assembly (AN) met again this Thursday, November 20, to authorize a 15-year extension for the oil joint ventures Petroperijá and Boquerón. Both operators promise to produce 91 million barrels of crude between 2026 and 2041, that is, 12 Mbpd through Petroperijá and 4 Mbpd from Boquerón, averages higher than their current production. However, if materialized, they would be relatively modest objectives for what the country needs to achieve.

Oil Operations

The Jose oil and petrochemical complex, on the country's northeastern coast, was the scene this week of a new industrial accident. At the PetroCedeño crude upgrader, the atmospheric distillation tower exploded due to exposure to abnormal pressures, likely caused by inadequate specifications for the processed crude. The explosion caused a fire that caused substantial damage to the facilities, affecting both production and refining. As is customary, PDVSA has not adequately reported on the event.

Due to the crude production shutdown related to the accident, production averaged eight hundred fifty-one thousand barrels per day (851 Mbpd) for the week, geographically distributed as follows:

·       West: 227 (Chevron: 108)

·       East: 117

·       Orinoco Belt: 507 (Chevron: 125)

·       TOTAL: 851 (Chevron: 233)

National refineries processed 231 Mbpd of crude and intermediate products, yielding 80 Mbpd of gasoline and 77 Mbpd of diesel.

The petrochemical sector continues to be affected by limited natural gas availability, with operations at methanol plants (Metor and Supermetanol) and fertilizer plants (Fertinitro) below their design capacity. In contrast, the SuperOctanos plant remains out of service.

November exports are averaging below 610 Mbpd due to delays in loading vessels during the Jose accident and the availability of crude in specification. Destinations for exported crude and products are limited to China, the U.S., and Cuba.

We estimate the weighted price of exported crude at $30.1/bbl.

[1]: International Analyst [2]: Nonresident Fellow Baker Institute

 

2025, ANOTHER TYPICALLY ATYPICAL YEAR

El Taladro Azul M. Juan Szabo [1] y Luis A. Pacheco [2] Published  Originally in Spanish in    LA GRAN ALDEA      The year 2025, the final y...